Major League Soccer (MLS) has seen many talented goalkeepers grace its fields, with some leaving a lasting legacy through their performances, leadership, and shot-stopping ability. Here is a detailed look at the 10 best goalkeepers in MLS history, based on their achievements, consistency, and impact on the league.
1. Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake, D.C. United, Miami Fusion)
Nick Rimando is regarded as one of the greatest goalkeepers in MLS history. With his quick reflexes, leadership, and incredible penalty-saving record, Rimando set numerous records in the league.
Achievements:
MLS all-time leader in wins, clean sheets, and saves
2009 MLS Cup champion with Real Salt Lake
Multiple MLS All-Star appearances
2. Tim Howard (Colorado Rapids, MetroStars)
Tim Howard had a remarkable career in both MLS and Europe. After making a name for himself with the MetroStars, he became a Premier League star before returning to the Colorado Rapids, where he continued to showcase his world-class goalkeeping.
Achievements:
Over 100 appearances in MLS
Helped MetroStars reach their first U.S. Open Cup final
121 caps for the U.S. Men’s National Team
3. Brad Guzan (Atlanta United, Chivas USA)
Brad Guzan played a crucial role in Atlanta United’s success, bringing experience and composure to their defense. His commanding presence in goal helped Atlanta secure their first-ever MLS Cup.
Achievements:
2018 MLS Cup winner with Atlanta United
Key figure in Atlanta’s CONCACAF Champions League campaigns
Over 200 MLS appearances
4. Kevin Hartman (LA Galaxy, Kansas City Wizards, FC Dallas, New York Red Bulls)
Kevin Hartman was one of the most consistent goalkeepers in MLS history. Known for his shot-stopping and longevity, he played a key role for multiple clubs and won several major trophies.
Achievements:
2-time MLS Cup winner (1998, 2002)
Over 400 MLS appearances
Multiple MLS Best XI selections
5. Stefan Frei (Seattle Sounders FC, Toronto FC)
Stefan Frei is best known for his heroics with Seattle Sounders, especially in the MLS Cup Final against Toronto FC, where he made a legendary save that helped secure the title.
Achievements:
2-time MLS Cup winner (2016, 2019)
MLS Cup MVP (2016)
Over 100 clean sheets in MLS
6. Tony Meola (Kansas City Wizards, MetroStars)
A legend of American soccer, Tony Meola was a dominant force in goal during his time in MLS. He was instrumental in Kansas City Wizards’ MLS Cup-winning campaign in 2000.
Achievements:
2000 MLS Cup champion
MLS MVP and Goalkeeper of the Year (2000)
Over 250 MLS appearances
7. Luis Robles (New York Red Bulls, Miami FC)
Luis Robles was a model of consistency and durability, holding the record for the most consecutive starts in MLS history. He was a leader for the New York Red Bulls for nearly a decade.
Achievements:
3-time Supporters’ Shield winner with New York Red Bulls
MLS Goalkeeper of the Year (2015)
Most consecutive MLS appearances (183 games)
8. Matt Turner (New England Revolution)
Matt Turner emerged as one of the best goalkeepers in recent MLS history before making a move to Europe. His shot-stopping ability and performances for the U.S. national team made him a standout.
Achievements:
MLS Goalkeeper of the Year (2021)
Helped New England win the Supporters’ Shield (2021)
Multiple MLS Best XI selections
9. Joe Cannon (San Jose Earthquakes, LA Galaxy, Colorado Rapids, Vancouver Whitecaps)
Joe Cannon was a two-time MLS Goalkeeper of the Year and one of the most reliable keepers of his generation. His performances helped San Jose Earthquakes win multiple trophies.
Achievements:
2-time MLS Goalkeeper of the Year (2002, 2004)
MLS Cup champion (2001)
Over 300 MLS appearances
10. Pat Onstad (D.C. United, Houston Dynamo, San Jose Earthquakes)
Pat Onstad was a key figure in Houston Dynamo’s early success, helping the club win back-to-back MLS Cups in 2006 and 2007. His experience and leadership made him a vital part of his teams.
Achievements:
2-time MLS Cup champion (2006, 2007)
2-time MLS Goalkeeper of the Year
Over 200 MLS appearances
Conclusion
MLS has been home to many legendary goalkeepers who have left an indelible mark on the league. From Nick Rimando’s record-breaking career to Stefan Frei’s clutch performances, these shot-stoppers have shaped the history of the league. With the league continuing to grow, new goalkeepers will aim to add their names to this illustrious list.
